For hand-dipped chocolates in Tiffin and Upper Sandusky, OH, choose Neumeister’s Candy Shoppe & Ice Cream. With over 15 years of experience in the candy world, Neumeister’s Candy Shoppe & Ice Cream delivers a chocolate experience that’s rich, nostalgic, and undeniably delicious. Each piece of hand-dipped chocolate reflects our dedication to the craft and passion for quality. With locations in Tiffin and Upper Sandusky, OH, our locally loved shops are where unforgettable flavors come to life—one small batch at a time.
Stop by our shop and experience why customers keep coming back for our signature hand-dipped chocolates. With over 15 years of candy-making experience behind every bite, you’ll understand why our customers call it the best chocolate they’ve ever tried. Visit today or contact us at (419) 379-9088 to ask about custom gifts for customers, seasonal specials, chocolate-making and more.
At Neumeister’s, hand-dipped means exactly that—chocolates made the old-fashioned way with care and precision. We use high-quality chocolate blends, carefully tempered to achieve the perfect snap and melt-in-your-mouth texture. If it’s a creamy caramel square, a crisp butter toffee, or a fruit center dipped in dark chocolate, each treat reflects our high standards. You can taste the difference experience makes.
Our cases are filled with a rotating selection of classic and creative hand-dipped chocolates. Popular choices include chocolate-covered pretzels, peanut clusters, marshmallows, coconut haystacks, and more. Looking for something bold? Try our dark chocolate sea salt caramels or chocolate-dipped espresso beans. From milk to dark, simple to indulgent, we offer a little something for every chocolate lover who walks through our doors.
Unlike mass-produced chocolates, our hand-dipped treats are made in small batches for maximum freshness. This allows us to maintain quality and ensure consistency in every bite. Our team takes the time to get every detail right—from the temperature of the chocolate to the thickness of the coating. We don’t rush the process. That’s what makes our candy so special.
When you’re looking for a treat for yourself or the perfect gift, our hand-dipped chocolates are always a hit. We offer boxed assortments, holiday-themed treats, and custom orders for parties, weddings, and corporate events including gift baskets. With elegant packaging and irresistible flavor, our chocolates turn any moment into a celebration.
2447 W Market St
Tiffin, Ohio 44883
139 N Sandusky Ave
Upper Sandusky, OH 43351
Phone: (419) 379-9088
info@neumeisterscandy.com
Location: Upper Sandusky
Tuesday – Friday 10:00 a.m. – 5:00 p.m.
Saturday 10:00 a.m. – 2:00 p.m.
