Homemade Ice Cream
in Tiffin and Upper Sandusky, OH
Visit Neumeister’s Candy Shoppe & Ice Cream for the Best Frozen Treats Around
Neumeister’s Candy Shoppe & Ice Cream sells handcrafted homemade hand-dipped ice cream by Mark’s Home Made Ice Cream at our shops in Tiffin and Upper Sandusky, OH. If you’re a fan of the classics or on the hunt for something bold and original, our small-batch creations deliver rich flavor, smooth texture, and a little something extra you can’t find anywhere else.
From sunny afternoons to weekend outings, make Neumeister’s Candy Shoppe & Ice Cream your stop for handcrafted ice cream in Tiffin and Sandusky. With fresh ingredients, small-batch flavors, and a team that knows candy inside and out, you get more than just dessert—you get an experience worth sharing. Stop in or contact us (419) 379-9088 to ask about current flavors, custom orders, or seasonal specialties. Taste the difference that 15 years of sweet experience makes.
Made in Small Batches for Exceptional Flavor and Freshness
We don’t take shortcuts to our homemade hand-dipped ice cream by Mark’s Homemade Ice Cream. Every flavor is crafted in small batches using high-quality ingredients and time-honored techniques. This approach ensures our ice cream stays creamy, fresh, and full of bold flavor. From fresh strawberries to pure vanilla and Belgian chocolate, we handpick each ingredient for taste and quality you can see and feel.
Unique Flavors and Classic Favorites That Everyone Can Enjoy
Our menu changes with the seasons, and that’s part of the fun. You’ll find signature flavors like chocolate fudge swirl, salted caramel pretzel, peanut butter cup, and cookie dough—plus rotating specialties inspired by our house-made chocolates. Want something fruity and refreshing? Try our black raspberry or lemon sherbet. Looking for something indulgent? Ask about our chocolate truffle or butter pecan. There’s always something new to love.
Custom Sundaes, Cones, and Take-Home Pints for Every Occasion
Choose your homemade hand-dipped ice cream by Mark’s Homemade Ice Cream your way—no matter if it’s piled high in a waffle cone, layered into a sundae, or packed into a pint to take home. Customize it with our hand-dipped chocolate pieces, roasted nuts, rich sauces, or fresh whipped cream. Hosting a party? We offer take-home tubs and pre-packed cups for easy serving and zero hassle.
Experience You Can Taste in Every Scoop of Ice Cream
With more than 15 years in the candy world, we know how to balance sweetness, texture, and creativity. That same attention to detail that made our chocolates famous now defines our ice cream. We’ve taken everything we’ve learned about flavor and built a dessert menu that surprises and satisfies.
